LIC Life Insurance vs SBI Life Insurance in 2025: Which Is Better?
Which is the best LIC Life Insurance or SBI Life Insurance When it comes to life insurance in India, two names dominate the conversation: Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) and SBI Life Insurance. Both companies enjoy massive brand recognition, large customer bases, and extensive networks. But when you’re investing your hard-earned money for the security of your family, the big question arises — Which is better: LIC or SBI Life Insurance?
This article dives deep into customer experiences, claim settlement records, policy offerings, and real-world pros and cons. By the end, you’ll be equipped with enough clarity to decide which insurer is right for you.
The Legacy of LIC: Trust Backed by Sovereign Guarantee
LIC was founded in 1956 when the Government of India nationalized private insurance companies after several scams in the sector. Since then, LIC has stood as a state-owned insurer with a sovereign guarantee.
- Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR): LIC has consistently posted one of the highest claim settlement ratios in the industry. As of the latest IRDAI report, LIC’s CSR hovers around 98–99%, meaning that nearly all genuine claims are honored.
- Market Share: Despite competition from over 20 private insurers, LIC still controls more than 65–70% of India’s life insurance market.
- Branch Network: With 2400+ branches across India, LIC has unmatched reach, even in rural areas where private insurers rarely operate.
One customer who has held LIC policies for over a decade said:
“LIC is not the best investment in terms of returns, but when it comes to trust and assurance, I have never worried about whether my family will receive the claim. That peace of mind is why my father, and now I, continue with LIC.”
SBI Life Insurance: Modern, Diverse, and Expanding
SBI Life is a joint venture between the State Bank of India (SBI) and BNP Paribas Cardiff. Established in 2001, it quickly grew to become one of the largest private insurers in India.
- Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR): SBI Life has a CSR of around 96–97%, which is excellent but slightly lower than LIC.
- Product Portfolio: SBI Life offers a wide variety of modern insurance products — from ULIPs (unit-linked plans) to child plans, pension plans, protection plans, and money-back policies.
- Banking Tie-ups: With SBI’s customer base of over 100 million accounts, SBI Life has a natural advantage in cross-selling its policies to bank customers.
A customer who took SBI’s Smart Humsafar plan shared:
“The plan was convenient since my spouse and I both got covered, and premiums were flexible. But the service quality depends on the branch you interact with. Some agents are excellent; others don’t guide properly.”
Real Customer Experiences: The Good and the Bad
Experiences with LIC
- Positive:
- “I lost my father in 2021, and LIC settled the claim in less than 20 days. We didn’t have to run around much. That moment taught me why LIC is trusted.”
- “The agent explained everything upfront, and I never faced hidden charges. But yes, returns are quite low compared to mutual funds.”
- Negative:
- “LIC policies are sold as investment plans. In reality, the maturity value barely beats inflation. It’s better to take term insurance from LIC and invest the rest in equity or FD.”
- “Premiums are higher than private insurers, especially for term insurance.”
Experiences with SBI Life
- Positive:
- “SBI Life gave me flexible ULIP options, and my returns are market-linked. Over 10 years, the growth has been much better than my LIC endowment policy.”
- “The premium for term insurance was affordable compared to LIC, and I could buy it online.”
- Negative:
- “In Haryana, many claims were delayed, and I personally faced repeated document requests even after submitting everything.”
- “While availing a home loan, SBI staff enrolled me in a life insurance policy without my consent. Later, I found out I was paying extra through a personal loan for an insurance I never agreed to.”
This highlights an important point: misselling practices are more common in private insurers, though LIC is not completely free from such issues either.
LIC vs SBI Life: Key Comparison
| Feature | LIC Life Insurance | SBI Life Insurance |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | Public sector, Govt. of India backed | Private (SBI + BNP Paribas joint venture) |
| Claim Settlement Ratio | 98–99% | 96–97% |
| Sovereign Guarantee | Yes (Govt. guarantee on money invested) | No sovereign guarantee |
| Product Variety | Traditional policies, term plans, endowment | Modern ULIPs, child, pension, savings |
| Premiums | Higher, especially for term insurance | Lower, more competitive |
| Network Reach | 2400+ branches, pan-India, strong rural reach | Strong in urban centers, bank branches |
| Returns | 5–6% on average (low) | Higher if ULIPs/market-linked |
| Trust Factor | Extremely high due to government ownership | Mixed (trust issues in some cases) |
Which Should You Choose in 2025?
- Choose LIC if:
- You want maximum trust and safety.
- You live in smaller towns or rural areas with limited access to private insurers.
- You prefer traditional plans and are okay with lower returns.
- Choose SBI Life if:
- You want diverse plans like ULIPs, child plans, or pension schemes.
- You’re comfortable with private players and prefer competitive premiums.
- You are tech-savvy and prefer online policy servicing.
What are the benefits for TATA AIG Life insurance in 2025
Buying Guide: How to Choose Between LIC and SBI Life
- Identify Your Need:
- Protection (term insurance)?
- Investment (ULIPs)?
- Savings + Insurance (endowment/money-back)?
- Compare Premiums and Benefits:
Use online calculators on both LIC and SBI Life websites. - Check Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR):
Aim for 95% or above — both LIC and SBI Life qualify. - Agent/Service Quality:
Talk to existing customers in your circle. Sometimes, the agent makes all the difference. - Avoid Misselling:
Don’t buy just because your bank insists. Always read the policy document carefully. - Keep Insurance and Investment Separate:
Ideally, take a term plan (for protection) and invest your savings in mutual funds, FDs, or PPF.
What is the Better policy Health Insurance or Life Insurance
FAQs
1. Is LIC safer than SBI Life?
Yes. LIC is backed by a sovereign guarantee from the Government of India, making it the safest insurer in terms of capital security.
2. Which has better returns: LIC or SBI Life?
SBI Life offers higher returns if you choose ULIPs or market-linked plans. LIC’s traditional plans provide low but guaranteed returns.
3. Who has a better claim settlement ratio?
LIC leads slightly with ~99% vs. SBI Life’s ~96–97%.
4. Which is cheaper in terms of premiums?
SBI Life premiums are usually lower, especially for online term insurance. LIC’s premiums are higher but come with unmatched trust.
5. Should I rely only on LIC or SBI Life?
Not necessarily. You can take term insurance from LIC for trust and invest separately in other financial products, or explore SBI Life’s ULIPs for higher returns.
What is Car insurance why is Mandatory
Final Verdict
- LIC is unbeatable in trust, government backing, and claim settlement assurance. However, its policies often underperform in returns and come at higher premiums.
- SBI Life is modern, versatile, and affordable but suffers from occasional misselling and trust issues.
If your priority is guaranteed safety and legacy, LIC is still the gold standard in 2025. But if you are looking for flexibility, affordability, and higher potential returns, SBI Life deserves consideration.
The smartest approach? Take term insurance from LIC (for peace of mind) and invest your savings in mutual funds or SBI Life’s market-linked plans. That way, you get the best of both worlds.
